~ Rational Approach to HRT ~
? Meaningful numbers of
women do not respond to traditional HRT dosing.
å The varied reasons
for a woman’s idiosyncratic response to hormonal therapy
include:
- differences in absorption of estrogen and progestins
- the state of the absorbed hormone in plasma
- the way in which the sex steroids bind with the target
tissues
- the distribution of a-estrogen or b-estrogen receptors
in the patient’s
estrogen-responsive organs
? Individualizing HRT: a
scientific approach maximizes benefits
– Women who have or are
risk for cardiovascular disease, osteoporosis, and
Alzheimer’s disease benefit from its use.
– Cardiovascular disease:
j Coronary artery disease
(CAD):
Oral esterified estrogens and transdermal
estrogens do not increase plasma
triglycerides and are preferred in women with
hypertriglyceridemia.
k Diabetics:
Oral esterified estrogens and transdermal
estrogens are also preferable.
è Clinical
application:
- Before initiating HRT, evaluate results from
a patient’s fasting glucose and a lipid
profile (including total cholesterol, HDL-c,
triglycerides, and calculated LDL-c)
- Based on the results of the fasting glucose,
lipid profile, and selectively measured
plasma estradiol levels, the type, dose, and route of HRT
prescribed can be
individualized for each woman who has or at risk for
cardiovascular disease.
– Osteoporosis:
è Low-dose
esterified estrogen therapy increases lumbar spine BMD:
ESE Dose |
0.3mg/day |
0.625mg/day |
1.25mg/day |
E2 (pg/dL) |
22 |
29 |
43 |
64 |
BMD |
-1.6… |
-1.2Ú |
2.0Ú |
3.7Ú |
E2 (pg/dL) |
14 |
24 |
41 |
58 |
BMD |
-2.0… |
1.5Ú |
3.0Ú |
4.6Ú |
E2 (pg/dL) |
16 |
26 |
40 |
60 |
BMD |
-2.9… |
1.9Ú |
3.0Ú |
5.0Ú |
… p <
0.05 from baseline Ú p <
0.05 from baseline and placebo
ESE: esterified estrogens Source: adopted from Genant HK, et
al.
è Choosing
and adjusting hormone therapy for osteopenia or osteoporosis:
Base-line Evaluation
– bone density
– bone markers
Low BMD Normal BMD
– Osteoporosis –
Osteopenia Bone turn over
(T-score > 2.5) (T-score 1-2.5)
– Osteopenia no fracture
Normal High
with fracture
Bone turn over No Rx. Low-dose estrogen (P)
oral or patch
Normal/low High Normal High Adjust annually with
BMD response
High-dose High-dose Low-dose Intermediate-dose
estrogen (P) estrogen (P) estrogen (P) estrogen (P)
oral or patch oral or patch oral or patch oral or patch
Add androgen
Lower to intermediate-dose Adjust dosage up or down
with response based on response
ø P: progestin/progesterone
(prescribing in intact uterus)
ø T-score: peak adult
bone mineral density.
1-2.5 SD: osteopenia, > 2.5
SD: osteoporosis
ø Estrogen dosing:
|
Low |
Intermediate |
High |
17b -estradiol |
0.5mg |
1mg |
2mg |
Esterified estrogens |
0.3mg |
0.625mg |
1.25mg |
CEE |
0.3mg |
0.625mg |
0.9mg |
E2 patch |
25mg |
50mg |
100mg |
– Alzheimer’s disease:
- Although there is still no consensus, some
studies report a 50% reduction in the incidence of
Alzheimer’s disease among estrogen users compared with
nonusers.
- Clinical application:
1. Identify women at risk for Alzheimer’s
disease as early as possible.
2. Determine if the individual’s cognition
will respond to estrogen therapy.
3. Decide on the dose and route of estrogen
therapy administration.
? Individualizing HRT:
balancing the risks
– The
reduction in cardiovascular disease, osteoporosis, and colon cancer associated
with HRT is
directly related to the biologic efficacy and continuance of
the prescribed therapy, because its
benefits are rapidly lost as soon as treatment is
stopped.Unfortunately, less than 30% of women
who start HRT continue for more than 1 year; fear of
breast cancer and resumption of
menstruation are two of the main reasons given for poor
compliance.
– Breast cancer:
P Despite more
than 40 observational studies, no consensus exists on breast cancer risk with
ERT. There is some agreement, however, that (1) the
relative risk for ERT-associated breast
cancer is time-dependent and increases by 30% to 40% after
10 to 15 years of ERT; and (2)
the higher dose of estrogen, the greater the potential
risk.
P Doses of
estrogen known to be effective in preventing osteoporosis and cardiovascular
disease (such as CEE 0.625mg and 17b
estradiol 1mg) are unlikely to be associated with
increased risk for breast cancer. Nor does adding progestin
appear to increase the risk.
P Clinical
application:
- have diagnostic-quality annual mammograms (and breast US
when indicated)
- be instructed in regular breast self-examination (weekly
exmanination)
- have the lowest dose of estrogen prescribed for her main
indication
- be treated with alternative modalities (when indicated)
plus exercise
– Endometrial cancer:
P Unopposed
estrogen increases the risk for endometrial adenocarcinoma 1.7- to 20-fold. This
cancer is also dose- and duration-related.
P Fortunately,
estrogen-induced endometrial cancer usually progresses gradually from simple
through complex hyperplasia without atypia, and complex
hyperplasia with celluar atypia, to
adenocarcinoma.
P Addition of progestins can
reverse the risk for endometrial hyperplasia. The type of progestin
prescribed has less impact on endometrial protection (cyclic,
which results in cyclic bleeding,
and continous)
– Resumption of
menstruation:
P When
bleeding is problematic enough to undermine the patient’s willingness to
continue
with the therapy, amenorrhea can be induced though
continuous combined estrogen and
progestin therapy. Depending upon the dose and potency of
estrogen, the amount of
progestin can be halved.
ø When 17b
estradiol 1mg is ordered, the daily doses for each progestin following
can be used: progesterone
100mg, provera
2.5mg, norethindrone
0.5mg.
P Continuous combined therapy
does not work for every woman. The dropout rate of women
on this treatment is directly related to the onset and
persistence of amenorrhea.
è Continuous
combined hormone therapy and amenorrhea:
Patients experiencing amenorrhea |
3 months |
6 months |
12 months |
Estradiol 1mg +
NETA 0.5mg |
94 |
86 |
94 |
10 |
CEE +
MPA 2.5mg |
52 |
63 |
75 |
40 |
CEE +
MPA 5.0mg |
57 |
72 |
89 |
40 |
NETA: norethindrone CEE: conjugated equine estrogens
MPA: medroxyprogesterone acetate, ie. proveraâ
Source: adopted from Stanberg E, et al, and Archer DF, et al
P To improve
patient acceptability of combined therapy, the progestin can be prescribed
for 2 weeks every 3 months, but higher doses of progestin
may be needed.
? Estrogen therapy:
selecting the route and dose
Considerations
Replacement of Hormonal milieu Replenishment of
premenopausal E2 > E1
postmenopausal E1 > E2
“ triglyceride, HTN,
Medical factors Low HDL
gallstones, DVT, DM
Prevention/maintenance Goal of therapy Treatment/correction
Lower dose Dose Higher dose
Side effects
Patient preference
Transdermal Oral
Monitor with periodic plasma and E2 testing
è Estimated
serum estradiol and estrone levels and biological potency after
oral estrogen therapy:
|
CEE (0.625mg) |
ME (1mg) |
EV (1mg) |
Estradiol (pg/mL) |
30-50 |
30-50 |
50 |
Estrone (pg/mL) |
153 |
150-300 |
160 |
Potency |
|
|
|
FSH |
1.4 |
1.3 |
N/A |
CBG |
2.5 |
1.9 |
N/A |
SHBG |
3.2 |
1.0 |
N/A |
A |
3.5 |
0.7 |
N/A |
CEE: conjugated equine estrogen CBG: cortisol binding
globulin
ME: micronized estrodiol SHBG: sex hormone binding globulin
EV: estradiol valerate A: serum angiotensiongen
Source: adopted from Levrant SG et al
ø Target tissue can
react only to free estrogen. The real potency of estrogen therapy
cannot be determined by clinically available assays
that measure only estradiol and
estrone.
? Recommended guidelines for
improving benefits and reducing risks of
estrogen therapy:
¾ Individualize
treatment with a comprehensive patient examination and
selective testing.
¾ Use the
lowest effective dose of estrogen and progestin/progesterone to
accomplish the therapeutic goal. Recent research shows that
ultra low doses of
estrogen can frequently meet the patient’s needs (for
example, the control of
vasomotor symptoms, improvement in lipid profile, and
prevention of bone
loss).
¾ Monitor the
woman’s response to therapy (initially 3 months after starting
therapy and thereafter annually) and adjust the treatment
accordingly.
¾ Choose the
route and type of estrogen therapy that will optimize compliance.
HRT is effective only as long as the patient takes it. If one
regimen is
unsuccessful, try other estrogen formulations instead of
discontinuing therapy.
¾ Consider the
use of measurable estrogens to mimic the hormonal milieu of
premenopausal (hormonal replacement therapy) or naturally
postmenopausal
women (hormonal replenishment therapy).
¾ Educate the
patient. Only an educated consumer can make informed decisions.
This leads to improved patient acceptance and continuance
with hormonal
therapy.
§ References:
1. Adjustive estrogen therapy: a rational approach to HRT.
Morris Notelovitz, MD, PhD.
Contemporary OB/GYN Feb., 1999.
Filename: Rational Approach to HRT
|